Who’s up for a Challenge - Part 4?
London Learning Networks have identified the following key features as being evident in all rich tasks:
- Develop learning from a common core of knowledge or skills
- Encourage exploration of a topic
- Allow a range of start and end points
- Have an element of open-endedness
- Can be accessed by a wide range of pupils of widely varying abilities
- Encourages critical thinking
- Encourages creativity
- Have an element of choice (either in task or in response) allowing pupils to exercise self-direction
- Are interesting and motivating for all pupils
- Provide varying levels of challenge – including very high challenge – to all
- Provide opportunities for able pupils to show what they’re capable of.
- 1/ Develop from a common core of knowledge or skills. Rich-tasks are based on a common core of work, generally one which would be covered by the class within their normal working day. In mathematics this might mean a task based around 3D shapes, for example. In science it might be based around the parts of a plant. The challenge is to take these common classroom tasks and enrich them. The core will generally encompass an element of subject material that the class needs to learn about or learn to do, such as labelling the relevant parts of a flower. The rich-task provides for this basic level of learning but also provides opportunities for pupils to move beyond it. See part 2 below.
- 2/ Encourage the exploration of a topic. Rich-tasks encourage pupils to explore the subject material, rather than merely provide an answer or complete a closely defined set of tasks. In the parts of a plant for example, students might be asked to compare different plants and note how their parts differ, or look at the parts of plants that grow in different environments and consider how and why they differ.
- 3/ Allow a range of start and end points. Pupils come to tasks from a wide range of backgrounds – some may have in-depth knowledge of a subject while others may have minimal or no knowledge. A well planned rich-task will allow for this, providing a range of choices that cater for all levels of abilities. Thus pupils who already know the key parts of a plant might go on to investigate plants in more detail, while those who do not know the key parts may start with learning the names for the parts and identifying them on a given plant. By the end of a task all the pupils will have gone far beyond this. The more open ended nature of the rich-task allows for allows for allows for a wide continuum of responses, thus providing for a wide range of abilities.
- 4/ Have an element of open-endedness. Most rich-tasks will have an element of open-endedness to them, to allow for the most able pupils. This does not mean that there is no right solution or end-product – rather, that there will be a range of them. They may have an initial, well-defined task that all pupils will be expected to achieve and then move on to more open ended tasks or the entire task may allow a wide range of possible responses. In English this might mean starting with a description of a person in a story than going on to compare this person with others of a similar nature in different stories. In mathematics it might start from measuring the interior angles in triangles, move on to comparisons with four sided figures and finally look at how the number of sides might be linked to the interior angles. There is generally no ‘set’ way of answering at least part of the task – pupils will approach the task differently depending on their learning styles and current levels of knowledge and ability.
- 5/ Can be accessed by pupils of widely varying abilities. A classical mathematical example is ‘explore ways to make 32’. A less able child might respond by noting that 1+1+1+…..=32. They might then see what happens when they add in two’s. More able pupils might start with numbers that add or subtract to make 32 but then quickly move on to using division or multiplication, or combinations of all four operations. Questions related to the starting question may prompt further investigation, for those who are capable of it.
- 6/ Encourage and provide for higher-level thinking in a supportive environment. The open-ended nature of rich-tasks will provide opportunities for higher level thinking, if the classroom environment supports this approach. If teachers comment positively on work that goes beyond the bare minimum and are interested in different approaches to tasks, then pupils will feel encouraged and supported in responding to rich tasks to the best of their ability. In a tightly constrained class, where there is one ‘right’ answer the teacher is the only authority, pupils will focus on providing what they feel the teacher is looking for. This will limit the richness of the response.
- 7/ Encourage critical thinking. Rich tasks will ask pupils to analyse, synthesise and/or evaluate in the course of completing the task. Rich tasks are not about simple recall of facts or repetition of learned procedures; they require higher level cognitive processing. Facts and procedures may be the starting point for some rich tasks but they are not the end point. Rich tasks encourage pupils to think creatively,work logically, synthesise their results, analyse disparate viewpoints, look for common features or evaluate findings. This is not to say that rich tasks might not include lower level of activities, such as knowing (learning) the parts of a plant.
- 8/ Encourage creativity. Rich tasks give pupils permission to be creative in their responses. As with higher level thinking, the level of creativeness will also depend on the nature of the classroom – in a tightly constrained classroom pupils may not feel that creativeness is either allowed or welcomed
- 9/ Have an element of choice (either in the task or the response). An element of choice, both in task and in end product, allows pupils to work to their strengths and interests. Choices should be varied to ensure that pupils encounter a wide range of tasks and products over the course of the school year. If we look just at the synthesis level of Bloom’s taxonomy, this will mean that pupils may be asked to arrange, assemble, collect, compose, construct, create, design, develop, formulate, manage, organise, plan, prepare, propose, set up and write. The end product could be written or oral, a model, presentation, in interview or debate. Choices allow pupils to feel ownership of the task or tasks and research shows that this is, in turn, will increase their level of effort, engagement and enjoyment.
- 10/ Are interesting and motivating for the pupil. The range of choice and challenge in rich tasks make them inherently more interesting to pupils. Tightly contained tasks with a set end point tend to allow pupils no individuality in either their approach or their output. All correct answers to 65 x 2 will be the same. The interest is in the end product or solution, with little or no interest in the process for getting there. In a rich task, pupils have choices to make. Teachers will tend to be interested in how they arrived at their chosen endpoint and why the pupils made the choices they did. All of this makes the rich tasks more interesting for both pupil and the teacher. Often teachers will be surprised at the work that pupils produce as a result of such choice.
- 11/ Provide varying levels of challenge including very high challenge to all. Rich tasks make high levels of challenge available to all pupils – not just those at the top end. There is always a ‘next step’ within a rich task, so that pupils can work to their ability, whatever that might be. Rich tasks provide underperforming pupils with opportunities to stretch and challenge themselves in a non-threatening environment. Questioning pupils as they work may increase the challenge, for example, asking pupils to look for patterns, to design a method to set out their work more logically, or to look for all solutions.
- 12/ Provide opportunities for students to show what they’re capable of achieving. Rich tasks have proven to be very helpful in identifying able or gifted pupils particularly those who are ‘hidden’ or unidentified. This open-ended nature and high levels of challenge provide opportunities for pupils to show what they are capable of achieving. They also allow a finer grained analysis of individual strengths and weaknesses than tightly constrained tasks.
5) Lessons which challenge learners through questioning and critical thinking - questioning is a fundamental part of teaching because it allows teachers to question students and students to question teachers. By Samantha Hopkins (Tywnham School)
Questioning is one of the most powerful tools a teacher has because questioning skills are central to the repertoire of teaching because they provide the greatest insight into students level of understanding. Good questions are amongst the most sensitive, subtle and useful skills in any teacher’s teaching and assessment repertoire, because the evidence becomes self-evident.
Questioning is one of the most important tools of any teachers day-to-day teaching practice. It provides opportunities for the development of knowledge and understanding, and also enables teachers to assess this knowledge and understanding through the responses provided. Also it helps students to clarify any topics or issues not fully understood.
Questions are particularly useful when stretching and challengingstudents. This is because questions can stimulate recall, deepen understanding, develop imagination and encourage problem solving . More importantly questions help students construct their own meaning especially when trying to make connections between more complex ideas. There are a number of ways which questioning can be used:
- capturing pupil’s attention and interest;
- recalling and checking on prior knowledge and challenging with new knowledge;
- focusing pupils’ attention on a specific issue or concept;
- checking and probing pupils’ understanding;
- developing pupils’ thinking and reasoning;
- differentiating learning through graduated challenges;
- extending pupils’ power of analysis and evaluation through challenging questions;
- helping pupils to reflect on how they learn through challenging teaching methods like reciprocal teaching.
When you walk into a lesson where the teacher is talking and you immediately think, ‘Yes, this is a great lesson’, what is happening? It is this: the teacher is asking probing questions. This is what they could be saying:
• That’s interesting, what makes you say that?
• That’s true, but why do you think that is?
• Is there a different way to say the same thing?
• Can you give an example of where that happens?
• Can you explain how you worked that out?
• So what happens if we made it bigger or smaller?
• Really? Are you sure? Is there another explanation?
• Which of those things makes the biggest impact?
• What is the theme that links all those ideas together?
• What is the evidence that supports that suggestion?
• Does anyone agree with that? Why?
• Does anyone disagree? What would you say instead? Why is that different?
• How does that answer compare to that answer?
• But what’s the reason for that? And how is that connected to the first part?
• How did you know that? What made you think of that? Where did that idea come from?
• Is that always true or just in this example?
• What would be the opposite of that?
• Is it true for everyone or just some people?
• Is that a direct cause of the effect or is it just a coincidence, a correlation?
• Not sure if that’s quite right… have another go… is that what you meant?
• That’s the gist of it… but is could you say that more fluently?
Spontaneously, as an interlocking element, the whole-class exchange is re-directed regularly so students discuss in pairs or groups, giving everyone an opportunity to engage. Here, the students adopt the modelled approach and begin to probe themselves… they ask each other questions in a probing style:
Is it is A or B… does it get bigger or smaller? Why does it get smaller? And how does that work? Do we have enough for a 4 mark answer? Have we explained it enough? …
Then, the probing continues as the teacher circulates or when the class is brought back.