Making Groups Work
We often think that students will engage successfully with group work activities and discussions because they are so keen to talk to each other at other times. Often, however, only a small proportion of the time is spent on our topic and then only a small proportion of the students are engaged with that task even though many are talking. When we ask for feedback, the more confident students are often able to give quite a decent answer off the cuff because they are orally confident. Dig a bit deeper and the contribution drops off quite quickly. Teachers often don't thoroughly engage with the group activity by listening in hard and it can be an opportunity to "just do that little job". (OK so maybe that's a bit cynical.)
Last year at the invitation of the Open University and Cindy Kerawalla, some of us have been experimenting with a little programme called the TALK FACTORY. Although I was a bit sceptical, I have been hugely impressed by the positive impact this simple easy to use bit of software has had on the quality of group dynamics, quality of conversation, and quality of discussion outcomes, all through a bit of electronic reward. Essentially you have to set up some simple rules for engagement. These then become interactive - when you click on them, a bar graph grows to indicate what they are doing well and a time line along the bottom shows when and when they are not doing so well. The students do their best to be rewarded, so there are usually many more positives.
I have attached a link to a how to do it guide and you can download the software from the O.U. at http://www8.open.ac.uk/creet/main/TalkFactory. Ask your IT Technician to install it. It works best with an Interactive board, but you could just use a laptop on a desk, or with a projector, or as I did the first time I used it - with a print out of the screen and a 5 bar tally chart.
Finally, I have started using a topic wordmat with it, to support their oral contribution with more varied vocabulary.
For example, doing some discussion work about Hazards with Year 7 about which was the most serious hazard from a volcano and why, one boy said "Ash is the biggest hazard". Another in his group then said, "no that's not enough we need a bit more" - looked at the word mat and then said "how about suffocating ash, then we know why the ash is a problem."
Link to help sheet
We often think that students will engage successfully with group work activities and discussions because they are so keen to talk to each other at other times. Often, however, only a small proportion of the time is spent on our topic and then only a small proportion of the students are engaged with that task even though many are talking. When we ask for feedback, the more confident students are often able to give quite a decent answer off the cuff because they are orally confident. Dig a bit deeper and the contribution drops off quite quickly. Teachers often don't thoroughly engage with the group activity by listening in hard and it can be an opportunity to "just do that little job". (OK so maybe that's a bit cynical.)
Last year at the invitation of the Open University and Cindy Kerawalla, some of us have been experimenting with a little programme called the TALK FACTORY. Although I was a bit sceptical, I have been hugely impressed by the positive impact this simple easy to use bit of software has had on the quality of group dynamics, quality of conversation, and quality of discussion outcomes, all through a bit of electronic reward. Essentially you have to set up some simple rules for engagement. These then become interactive - when you click on them, a bar graph grows to indicate what they are doing well and a time line along the bottom shows when and when they are not doing so well. The students do their best to be rewarded, so there are usually many more positives.
I have attached a link to a how to do it guide and you can download the software from the O.U. at http://www8.open.ac.uk/creet/main/TalkFactory. Ask your IT Technician to install it. It works best with an Interactive board, but you could just use a laptop on a desk, or with a projector, or as I did the first time I used it - with a print out of the screen and a 5 bar tally chart.
Finally, I have started using a topic wordmat with it, to support their oral contribution with more varied vocabulary.
For example, doing some discussion work about Hazards with Year 7 about which was the most serious hazard from a volcano and why, one boy said "Ash is the biggest hazard". Another in his group then said, "no that's not enough we need a bit more" - looked at the word mat and then said "how about suffocating ash, then we know why the ash is a problem."
Link to help sheet