May 2013

Who’s up for a Challenge - Part 4?

London Learning Networks have identified the following key features as being evident in all rich tasks:
  1. Develop learning from a common core of knowledge or skills
  2. Encourage exploration of a topic
  3. Allow a range of start and end points
  4. Have an element of open-endedness
  5. Can be accessed by a wide range of pupils of widely varying abilities
  6. Encourages critical thinking
  7. Encourages creativity
  8. Have an element of choice (either in task or in response) allowing pupils to exercise self-direction
  9. Are interesting and motivating for all pupils
  10. Provide varying levels of challenge – including very high challenge – to all
  11. Provide opportunities for able pupils to show what they’re capable of.
Key features of rich-tasks as identified by London Gifted & Talented organisation
  • 1/ Develop from a common core of knowledge or skills. Rich-tasks are based on a common core of work, generally one which would be covered by the class within their normal working day. In mathematics this might mean a task based around 3D shapes, for example. In science it might be based around the parts of a plant. The challenge is to take these common classroom tasks and enrich them. The core will generally encompass an element of subject material that the class needs to learn about or learn to do, such as labelling the relevant parts of a flower. The rich-task provides for this basic level of learning but also provides opportunities for pupils to move beyond it. See part 2 below.
  • 2/ Encourage the exploration of a topic. Rich-tasks encourage pupils to explore the subject material, rather than merely provide an answer or complete a closely defined set of tasks. In the parts of a plant for example, students might be asked to compare different plants and note how their parts differ, or look at the parts of plants that grow in different environments and consider how and why they differ.
  • 3/ Allow a range of start and end points. Pupils come to tasks from a wide range of backgrounds – some may have in-depth knowledge of a subject while others may have minimal or no knowledge. A well planned rich-task will allow for this, providing a range of choices that cater for all levels of abilities. Thus pupils who already know the key parts of a plant might go on to investigate plants in more detail, while those who do not know the key parts may start with learning the names for the parts and identifying them on a given plant. By the end of a task all the pupils will have gone far beyond this. The more open ended nature of the rich-task allows for allows for allows for a wide continuum of responses, thus providing for a wide range of abilities.
  • 4/ Have an element of open-endedness. Most rich-tasks will have an element of open-endedness to them, to allow for the most able pupils. This does not mean that there is no right solution or end-product – rather, that there will be a range of them. They may have an initial, well-defined task that all pupils will be expected to achieve and then move on to more open ended tasks or the entire task may allow a wide range of possible responses. In English this might mean starting with a description of a person in a story than going on to compare this person with others of a similar nature in different stories. In mathematics it might start from measuring the interior angles in triangles, move on to comparisons with four sided figures and finally look at how the number of sides might be linked to the interior angles. There is generally no ‘set’ way of answering at least part of the task – pupils will approach the task differently depending on their learning styles and current levels of knowledge and ability.
  • 5/ Can be accessed by pupils of widely varying abilities. A classical mathematical example is ‘explore ways to make 32’. A less able child might respond by noting that 1+1+1+…..=32. They might then see what happens when they add in two’s. More able pupils might start with numbers that add or subtract to make 32 but then quickly move on to using division or multiplication, or combinations of all four operations. Questions related to the starting question may prompt further investigation, for those who are capable of it.
  • 6/ Encourage and provide for higher-level thinking in a supportive environment. The open-ended nature of rich-tasks will provide opportunities for higher level thinking, if the classroom environment supports this approach. If teachers comment positively on work that goes beyond the bare minimum and are interested in different approaches to tasks, then pupils will feel encouraged and supported in responding to rich tasks to the best of their ability. In a tightly constrained class, where there is one ‘right’ answer the teacher is the only authority, pupils will focus on providing what they feel the teacher is looking for. This will limit the richness of the response.
  • 7/ Encourage critical thinking. Rich tasks will ask pupils to analyse, synthesise and/or evaluate in the course of completing the task. Rich tasks are not about simple recall of facts or repetition of learned procedures; they require higher level cognitive processing. Facts and procedures may be the starting point for some rich tasks but they are not the end point. Rich tasks encourage pupils to think creatively,work logically, synthesise their results, analyse disparate viewpoints, look for common features or evaluate findings. This is not to say that rich tasks might not include lower level of activities, such as knowing (learning) the parts of a plant.
  • 8/ Encourage creativity. Rich tasks give pupils permission to be creative in their responses. As with higher level thinking, the level of creativeness will also depend on the nature of the classroom – in a tightly constrained classroom pupils may not feel that creativeness is either allowed or welcomed
  • 9/ Have an element of choice (either in the task or the response). An element of choice, both in task and in end product, allows pupils to work to their strengths and interests. Choices should be varied to ensure that pupils encounter a wide range of tasks and products over the course of the school year. If we look just at the synthesis level of Bloom’s taxonomy, this will mean that pupils may be asked to arrange, assemble, collect, compose, construct, create, design, develop, formulate, manage, organise, plan, prepare, propose, set up and write. The end product could be written or oral, a model, presentation, in interview or debate. Choices allow pupils to feel ownership of the task or tasks and research shows that this is, in turn, will increase their level of effort, engagement and enjoyment.
  • 10/ Are interesting and motivating for the pupil. The range of choice and challenge in rich tasks make them inherently more interesting to pupils. Tightly contained tasks with a set end point tend to allow pupils no individuality in either their approach or their output. All correct answers to 65 x 2 will be the same. The interest is in the end product or solution, with little or no interest in the process for getting there. In a rich task, pupils have choices to make. Teachers will tend to be interested in how they arrived at their chosen endpoint and why the pupils made the choices they did. All of this makes the rich tasks more interesting for both pupil and the teacher. Often teachers will be surprised at the work that pupils produce as a result of such choice.
  • 11/ Provide varying levels of challenge including very high challenge to all. Rich tasks make high levels of challenge available to all pupils – not just those at the top end. There is always a ‘next step’ within a rich task, so that pupils can work to their ability, whatever that might be. Rich tasks provide underperforming pupils with opportunities to stretch and challenge themselves in a non-threatening environment. Questioning pupils as they work may increase the challenge, for example, asking pupils to look for patterns, to design a method to set out their work more logically, or to look for all solutions.
  • 12/ Provide opportunities for students to show what they’re capable of achieving. Rich tasks have proven to be very helpful in identifying able or gifted pupils particularly those who are ‘hidden’ or unidentified. This open-ended nature and high levels of challenge provide opportunities for pupils to show what they are capable of achieving. They also allow a finer grained analysis of individual strengths and weaknesses than tightly constrained tasks.
5) Lessons which challenge learners through questioning and critical thinking - questioning is a fundamental part of teaching because it allows teachers to question students and students to question teachers. By Samantha Hopkins (Tywnham School)

Questioning is one of the most powerful tools a teacher has because questioning skills are central to the repertoire of teaching because they provide the greatest insight into students level of understanding. Good questions  are amongst the most sensitive, subtle and useful skills in any teacher’s teaching and assessment repertoire, because the evidence becomes self-evident.

Questioning is one of the most important tools of any teachers day-to-day teaching practice.  It provides opportunities for the development of knowledge and understanding, and also enables teachers to assess this knowledge and understanding through the responses provided.  Also it helps students to clarify any topics or issues not fully understood. 
Questions are particularly useful when stretching and challengingstudents. This is because questions can stimulate recall, deepen understanding, develop imagination and encourage problem solving . More importantly questions help students construct their own meaning especially when trying to make connections between more complex ideas.  There are a number of ways which questioning can be used:
  • capturing pupil’s attention and interest;
  • recalling and checking on prior knowledge and challenging with new knowledge;
  • focusing pupils’ attention on a specific issue or concept;
  • checking and probing pupils’ understanding;
  • developing pupils’ thinking and reasoning;
  • differentiating learning through graduated challenges;
  • extending pupils’ power of analysis and evaluation through challenging questions;
  • helping pupils to reflect on how they learn through challenging teaching methods like reciprocal teaching.
Probing Questions
When you walk into a lesson where the teacher is talking and you immediately think, ‘Yes, this is a great lesson’, what is happening? It is this: the teacher is asking probing questions. This is what they could be saying:

•  That’s interesting, what makes you say that?
•  That’s true, but why do you think that is?
•  Is there a different way to say the same thing?
•  Can you give an example of where that happens?
•  Can you explain how you worked that out?
•  So what happens if we made it bigger or smaller?
•  Really?  Are you sure? Is there another explanation?
•  Which of those things makes the biggest impact?
•  What is the theme that links all those ideas together?
•  What is the evidence that supports that suggestion?
•  Does anyone agree with that? Why?
•  Does anyone disagree? What would you say instead? Why is that different?
•  How does that answer compare to that answer?
•  But what’s the reason for that? And how is that connected to the first part?
•  How did you know that? What made you think of that? Where did that idea come from?
•  Is that always true or just in this example?
•  What  would be the opposite of that?
•  Is it true for everyone or just some people?
•  Is that a direct cause of the effect or is it just a coincidence, a correlation?
•  Not sure if that’s quite right… have another go… is that what you meant?
•  That’s the gist of it… but is could you say that more fluently?

The natural tendency to hold exchanges like this with individuals or a whole class is a key feature of excellent teachers.  At a whole-class level, the dialogue is conducted with some energy and passion, moving from student to student, bringing the students from the back and the corners into the fray.  There is discipline; everyone listens to everyone else as the probing continues. Each respondent gets at least one teacher bounce-back but often repeated exchanges, dialogues, develop as deeper and deeper answers are sought.
Spontaneously, as an interlocking element,  the whole-class exchange is re-directed regularly so students discuss in pairs or groups, giving everyone an opportunity to engage. Here, the students adopt the modelled approach and begin to probe themselves… they ask each other questions in a probing style:
Is it is A or B… does it get bigger or smaller? Why does it get smaller? And how does that work?  Do we have enough for a 4 mark answer?  Have we explained it enough? …
Then, the probing continues as the teacher circulates or when the class is brought back.



Who’s up for a Challenge - Part 3?


1/Lessons which stretch the more able (G & T) this provides ideas for creating an environment which challenges gifted & talented students
What does excellent provision G & T students look like?
Research by the Villiers Park Educational Trust identified seven features that students’ identified as making a lesson an outstanding experience in terms of challenge and interest.
1. Setting the context
Context helps set the scene when covering a new topic and gives us an idea of when and where information will be useful in the future. It can also be used to link subjects together. We feel that it is likely to stimulate a higher level of interest if we understand the purpose of what we are learning – it prevents us dismissing something as irrelevant. We appreciate the danger of detracting from the syllabus and would welcome a reduction in its size to allow time for explaining the context. If this is not an option, it is still possible to cover context in a relatively short time bearing in mind the impact this can have on motivation.
- Consider what approaches you, your department  use to help students when you are introducing a new topic.
2. Project work
We refer here to creative exercises that involve perhaps only a small amount of lesson time, but the scope to continue if we want outside of the classroom. Projects spark interest in a topic, encourage research, and give the opportunity for those who are interested to delve into a topic in far greater depth. We recognise potential problems such as students going off track and if part of a group activity, one person doing far more than their fair share. To get round this, teacher supervision needs to be carefully structured.
– Does your department use project work to challenge students through research? If you do what approach do you use to introduce project work? Do you ease students into such schemes or do you simply give one large project for them to complete? Have you ever considered giving your students a whole topic to study/research on their own as a means of reducing your workload? It might be useful to discuss the advantages / disadvantages of such a method
 3. A lingering thought-provoking idea
At the end of a class the teacher could present an open-ended question that requires consideration beyond the classroom. Ideas can be taken up in the next lesson with students volunteering to provide answers.
4. Enthusiastic Teachers
We assume that all teachers are enthusiastic, but how should this show itself in the eyes of the students? We look for a teacher who has prepared the lesson well, who takes an interest in each individual, and who conveys their subject in a way that is both educational and entertaining. An enthusiastic teacher encourages enthusiasm amongst their students. It would help if teachers were given more freedom to personalise their lessons, including scope to give their own opinions. We recognise that the wider working environment might influence teacher enthusiasm.
 How enthusiastic are you? Is it even possible to tell or measure a teacher’s enthusiasm? Do you think enthusiasm is important to teaching & learning?
5. Challenging Lessons
We all agreed that this was essential and we attempted to identify what the phrase means. It is when the content goes further than the syllabus with students pushed beyond their usual limits. Quite possibly unconventional ideas will have been introduced. The lessons should be structured but unpredictable and if they are successful they will have kept the students interested throughout. The key constraints might be that fellow students are unable to keep up or feel alienated. If challenging work can’t be provided for some students within a class, maybe there should be separate classes for the more able or smaller classes or perhaps higher level lessons should take place outside of school.
Do you see challenging lessons as something which ought to be in all lessons or something used occasionally?
 6. Discussion and Presentations
We enjoy the opportunity to give opinions. More students are likely to be involved if at least sometimes the discussions take place in small groups rather than for the whole class. Teaching time could be saved if each group is given a different aspect to cover and feeds back to others. We think that this type of opportunity to teach others improves understanding and in general, active learning results in better recall. Potential dangers include students not working together effectively, but if teachers set up the groups carefully, give clear instructions, and impose time restrictions for each task, then it can be successful. “Talk Factory could be a tool for directing useful group work.
7. Relationships
It is important for a teacher to get to know the members of their class. This will allow them to tailor work to suit each individual’s interests and abilities. From our point of view, it would make teachers more approachable, earn respect, and help to create a friendly atmosphere. This in turn would make it more comfortable for us to ask questions. There is a danger within such an environment of boundaries becoming blurred and discipline suffering. However, if teachers act professionally, avoiding favouritism and bias, perhaps by allocating equal time to each student, this threat can be overcome


Who’s up for a Challenge -part 2 ?

"Rigour is part of a great teacher’s attitude.  You don’t settle for sloppy thinking, mediocrity, half-hearted writing or incomplete answers.  You can’t do a bit of rigour every now and then; it is part and parcel of every lesson, relentless and automatic."


“Who says this works?” and “Where’s the evidence?”

Two of the main advocates of these methods have come from Professor John Hattie and Geoff Petty. 

 Geoff Petty
We learn by doing. Research shows that active learning is much better recalled, enjoyed and understood. Active methods require us to 'make our own meaning' , that is, develop our own conceptualisations of what we are learning. During this process we physically make neural connections in our brain, the process we call learning. Passive methods such as listening do not require us to make these neural connections or conceptualisations.
 Active methods also:

• Give the learner feedback on their incomplete understandings and encourage them fix this, for example by helping each other.
• Give the teacher feedback on which learners understand, and who needs help
• Develop thinking skills such as analysis, problem solving, and evaluation
• Help learners to use their learning in realistic and useful ways, and see its importance and relevance
• Are more fun!
• Give the teacher a bit of a rest

Professor John Hattie analysed 200,000 ‘effect-sizes’ from 180,000 studies representing 50+million students and covering almost every method of teaching available. His findings have gone on to help develop teachers to:
•         advance learner’s achievement by one year, or improving the rate of learning by 50%  
•         a two grade leap in GCSE, e.g. from a C to an A grade
Hattie argues that the ultimate challenge is for the teacher to “spend more time and energy understanding learning through the eyes of students”. This means understanding where the students are at, giving them appropriate feedback, and seeing where the students are through their eyes rather than those of the teacher.

LOW  CHALLENGE: In my experience, the most common reason for lessons to be sub-standard is that there isn’t enough challenge:
•         Students are engaged in tasks that are low level; they may be ‘working’ but they are not thinking. Or the thinking could be meaningless

•         I’ve been in lessons such as this where a student has shown me her impressive diagrams of the cirque formation and her completed Assignment Sheet….but could not tell me a single thing about it; she did not understand any of what she’d copied.  It is possible to transfer and re-arrange  a stack of information from A to B without learning a thing.

•         Failure to establish prior knowledge and understanding is another common cause. Superficially students are busy, but they are just going over old ground….or expectations are simply too low.  Students in Y9 making a Valentine’s card on Publisher with clip art…… ! They do that in Y3.

•         For me the worst symptom of a  ‘low challenge’ disposition is a teacher who gives away the answers too cheaply; no struggle time…almost a fear of the silence that follows a question…and before you know it, they’ve all been put out of their misery.

•         An extension of that is  recipe syndrome.  “Follow these instructions, exactly, and you can’t go wrong” ….need I say more. 

•          A pet hate of mine is being in a lesson where it is clear (to me) that the students are screaming.. JUST LET ME GET ON WITH IT… but the teacher just needs to give out another 10 bits of info, reminders and warnings….

•         Anxious to get on with the lesson or to get through the material, teachers can by-pass the thinking and learning by denying students the opportunity to process, to struggle, to make choices and to make mistakes. The same happens if teachers are too control-freaky and can’t bear the ‘chaos’ of students getting themselves into groups or thinking for themselves.

•         HIGH CHALLENGE : Where teachers have an instinct for challenge, this is the sort of thing you see:
•         Deep End instructions.  In setting up a task, there is a brief overview and then “Off you go…” Students have to engage with the challenge, make decisions, check for understanding and then get started, drawing on the resources at their disposal.  Deep End practical work in Science is great example: “We’re exploring circuits; there is the stuff; off you go…..”
•         Think, pair, share.   In high challenge lessons, this mode of questioning is absolutely standard; it is the default mode, with plenty of time for the thinking.
•          Struggle Time.  Teachers are often phobic about seeing students struggle – and this transfers to the students.  Panic and self-defeatism ensue.  Unfortunately,  from a young age, children learn that mistakes are a bad thing.. and, therefore, something must be wrong if you don’t get it.  Great teachers brave it out….they convey confidence that, with persistence, solutions will come after some thought.
•         Probing Questions, –plus the habit of reversing the process whereby students devise questions.
•         Synoptic Tasks: Too much subject content is compartmentalised but high challenge lessons are about making connections.  An example of this is particular Y10 Geography lesson where students evaluate the causes, impacts of and the cost/benefit strategies to alleviate flooding in Carlisle.  This involves looking at the geology, hydrology, climate, town development, transport and various other factors, to evaluate a range of options, taking into account a range of the data. All the content areas layer up into one almighty challenge with huge rewards.  There are lots of other examples where multiple examples or sources are studies or where different concepts in the subject (Maths, Science, Languages).. are linked together, routinely, every lesson.

•         Problem solving.  In a lot subjects, too much emphasis is placed on straight content.  In great lessons, the challenge comes to the fore through applying knowledge to problems. 

•        Cognitive Conflict: An idea from CASE and CAME.  There is no space to describe this in detail but these should be familiar to Maths and Science teachers.  The King’s College ‘cognitive acceleration’ programmes originating in the late 1980s, are absolutely superb and define a whole approach that embraces the notion of cognitive conflict. CASE is now published as Thinking Science  Students have to wrestle with the notion of fair testing, controlling variables, sample size and so on.  The key to the activities is that the teacher needs to allow the students to struggle – to experience ‘cognitive conflict’ – before they make the connections. Giving them the answers doesn’t work.

•         Collaborative group work – When students in groups are set a clear goal, and roles are defined within groups to avoid passenger-syndrome, the level of challenge can be massive  Group work should not require massive planning; the elements of effective, challenging group work should be routine, something a great teacher could spontaneously introduce in any lesson.
•         Self-directed progression.  This approach allows students to experience skateboarding-style flow in regular lessons. For example in maths, students can work through levels of questions of increasing difficulty by self-checking answers as they go.  Or, a series of tasks (using text books or other resources) can be made available and students can be given freedom to select their own sequence;  this might include asking students to select which questions to answer so that they are working at the optimal challenge level.
•         Pace.   Pace through depth and not speed’ is a valid concept.  Pace can be fast or slow. Learning takes the time it takes.  However, sometimes, a faster pace is needed and challenge emerges from creating a sense of urgency.  For example in Technology and Art – or in extended book work – students can drift; they can dabble, dawdle and get lulled into a passive mode.  Great teachers use time indicators, setting time-goals for task that inject an appropriate level of urgency.
•         Reciprocal teaching.  A superb, routine way to ensure challenge is to ask students to explain concepts back to you, to each other or to another audience through some form of publication or piece of writing.  This is a high effect-size mode of learning in Hattie’s work.  Routine use of ‘explain that back to me’ or ‘explain it to each other and report what the other person said’ in classroom exchanges, is highly effective.

Really, the list of high-challenge activities is endless.  However, as with all these ideas, the over-riding thing is that they stem from a general disposition towards embracing high challenge.  At the heart of this is a belief that thinking and struggling are prerequisites  for learning and that there is nothing to fear.

It is always true that great lessons are characterised by a high level of rigour.
The nature of rigour can be highly subject specific, but there are some over-arching characteristics:
•         The teacher pitches the material very high; there is no doubt that the most able students in the room are challenged and engaged.
•         The teacher presents a strong command of the subject and uses that to select appropriately probing questions and tasks… this may come across as ‘passion’ but not necessarily. Rigour isn’t about excited enthusiasm; that is not what we’re talking about here.
•         The teacher can respond intelligently to questions and can back-fill or widen discussion with examples, counter-examples and tangential ideas.
•         Students are required to give precise answers, extended answers and answers that focus on the Why and How… not just the What.
•         The use of accurate subject specific language is expected and reinforced.
•         The teacher is prepared to challenge and accept challenge back; it matters that things are right – or that they are examined for truth and the general tone of the lesson is one of searching ever deeper.
•         There is usually a general sense of high expectations in range of areas: concentration span; extended writing; independence and self-help; maturity and sophistication etc. All these things reinforce a rigorous approach to learning in the classroom.
•         The focus is on intrinsic reward and motivation through the learning; rigour is rarely associated with ‘having a bit of fun’.. but actually, in great lessons, students get engrossed in rigorous tasks and enjoy the feeling of making progress.  Serious endeavour, rigour and enjoyment are intertwined… a great teacher never dumbs it down or suggests that the ‘fun’ is all the easy stuff.
From Tom Sherrington, Headteacher and a teacher @KEGS_Chelmsfordheadguruteacher.com

Newer Posts Older Posts