AfL Revisited

It is now 15 years since the publication of Inside the Black Box by P. Black and D. Wiliam, the influential pamphlet that started the AfL ball rolling!
As so much time has passed there may be the development of a perception that AfL is ‘old hat’ and that the world of education has moved on to other ‘more exciting things’. AfL is so often the missing ingredient in lessons that can turn a good to outstanding.
We should not think of formative assessment as a series of activities that we dip into, or show-case lessons that we turn on when necessary; truly embedded AfL should manifest itself in every lesson.
 
The Spirit of AfL.
There are, of course, specific activities and strategies than enable us to develop our AfL practice There is a definite difference between lessons where teachers employ set-piece ‘Afl activities’ and those where the teacher models the practice at a more intuitive level. (This is described as the “Spirit of AFL”). Research suggests that where the ‘spirit’ of AfL predominates, lessons are more successful than those that only follow ‘tick-box’ strategies – working to the ‘letter’ of AfL. An example might be where a teacher naturally encourages students to discuss and share the successful features of a piece of work—the success criteria— as opposed to always giving out a ‘tick-box’ template with pre-set criteria determined by the teacher without student input. (I’m probably guilty of this one, but a balance of both approaches is healthy.)
 
It isn’t the school, the Headteacher or the class size that makes the most difference—it is the teacher – YOU!
 
  The implication is clear enough. If we all strive to embrace the spirit of AfL in our everyday practice, we will become more effective teachers.
 
Assessment for Learning Self-Evaluation Statements

 
Assessment for Learning Self-Evaluation Statements
 
1
I routinely take time to establish what all my students already know or can already do and use this to plan subsequent lessons and differentiation strategies.
 
2
I establish explicit success criteria for an extended task and share this with students before they make a start.
 
3
If students are going to be given grades for work, I make explicit what is required for each grade in advance.
 
4
I often use an all-student response system like mini-whiteboards so that I can see how each student has responded to a question. (Do you have a set of whiteboards to hand at all times?)
 
5
I usually ask students to discuss answers in pairs or groups rather than asking for hands up and use strategies that ensure all students answer all questions.
 
6
I usually select students randomly to answer questions instead of them putting hands up.
 
7
I routinely demand extended answers from students and ask them to explain why or how they came to that answer.
 
8
I regularly use student exemplars to model learning outcomes e.g. using a visualiser.
 
9
I structure group work so that everyone has a role in the group, contributes to the task and has to prepare to give feedback to the class if asked.
 
10
I routinely use peer and self assessment activities to help students gauge their progress and identify areas of uncertainty.
 
11
I give students opportunities to act on any feedback I give to improve their work including redrafting work, making corrections or re-running presentations or discussing wrong answers in tests.
 
 
Have you got the spirit?
 

Each subject has different learning approaches that work best and teachers have personal preferences and styles but here is a list of questions you might find helpful in prompting you to think about your own practice. If you feel you often adopt these strategies without thinking too much, then you are likely to be someone for whom the spirit of AfL comes naturally. However, that normally emerges after a period of planned experimentation. For example, you  insist that every student  answers every question in pairs before sharing with the class – instead of responding to students putting their hands up . The next step is to make the decision that this is how you will ask questions from now on. In all of these areas, a deliberate plan to adopt the strategy is the fore-runner to developing the practice to the point that it is routine.


The Tools of AfL: some routines and some bits of kit.
Think—Pair –Share:
ensure everyone answers every question, with time to think, time to struggle, and space to say ‘I don’t get it’ if they need to.
Mini-whiteboards:
get feedback from everyone in the class-rights answers, wrong-answers, alternative answers, misconceptions and cries for help. Create a risk-free wipe-clean ephemeral space for trying out ideas and practicing.
Visualisers:
(Ipads / tablets & iPhones can do the same job)
provide instant feedback, model standards using current student work—as well as being a versatile visual aid, eg for going over exam papers or showing stimulus material. The ability to annotate and highlight resources or student work is powerful.
The Big Picture:
topic overview, exam specification, project outline. Give students all the information they need to learn independently.
Assessment Criteria:
provide access to the most explicit criteria you can to enable students to know about the standards they are aiming to meet. What, exactly, is required for an A* grade? It shouldn’t be a mystery.
Exemplar Material:
show students what an A* essay /paragraph /answer / composition looks like in order to tease out the precise meaning of standards or assessment objectives
Time to act on feedback:
ensure lesson routines include the process of acting on feedback from marking, tests or peer assessment.

Feedback
• Feedback activities should enable pupils to understand how to improve their work
• Teachers should systematically and effectively check pupils’ understanding throughout lessons
Outstanding Teaching; OfSTED Framework 2012
Naturally, a key element of AfL practice is in how feedback is given and the way it is use to build into loops of continuous improvement.
Observations and discussions with teachers and Heads of Department suggest that a possible weak link in working with students  not making the expected progress —marking it as an area for making gains— is in ensuring that  the ”gap is closed”, especially with weaker students.
What does this mean?
AfL strategies should continually provide both feedback to the teacher about how each student is performing and feedback to the student about how they are performing. This should  lead to targets that highlight a set of ‘next steps’ that the student needs to take to make the expected progress. The crunch comes in making sure that each student actually takes those steps. This is what it takes to “close the gap”.
This process shouldn’t be optional so, clearly, this is where motivational factors come into play. If a student is highly self-motivated, they will act on feedback and strive to improve.
Teachers obviously play a key role in fuelling that motivation – with positive reinforcement of every gain coupled with a level of expectation that is non-negotiable. AfL is not woolly and wishful; at the sharp end the teacher-student relationship needs to involve a clear-cut understanding that if we have taken the trouble to map out the next steps in a student’s learning, they had better take them!
A helpful way to examine the concept and  challenge of formative assessment in the context of lessons is to think about Dylan Wiliam’s five key strategies:
• Clarifying, understanding, and sharing learning intentions
• Engineering effective classroom discussions, tasks and activities that elicit evidence of learning
• Providing feedback that moves learners forward
• Activating students as learning resources for one another
• Activating students as owners of their own learning

This covers just about everything we might think of doing in a lesson! Essentially AfL has three components:

First, learners need to establish where they are in their knowledge and understanding.
“What do I know already?”
Then, they need to establish clearly where they want to go.
“What are the standards or skill levels I am aiming for?”
Finally they need to know how to get there from where they are.
“What, exactly, do I need to do now to make progress?”

Crucially, these steps take the learners’ viewpoint— not the teacher’s; our role is to enable students to make this journey;  we cannot make it for them.

Newer Post Older Post