Who’s up for a Challenge - Part 3?
1/Lessons which stretch the more able (G & T) this provides ideas for creating an environment which challenges gifted & talented students
What does excellent provision G & T students look like?
Research by the Villiers Park Educational Trust identified seven features that students’ identified as making a lesson an outstanding experience in terms of challenge and interest.
1. Setting the context
Context helps set the scene when covering a new topic and gives us an idea of when and where information will be useful in the future. It can also be used to link subjects together. We feel that it is likely to stimulate a higher level of interest if we understand the purpose of what we are learning – it prevents us dismissing something as irrelevant. We appreciate the danger of detracting from the syllabus and would welcome a reduction in its size to allow time for explaining the context. If this is not an option, it is still possible to cover context in a relatively short time bearing in mind the impact this can have on motivation.
- Consider what approaches you, your department use to help students when you are introducing a new topic.
2. Project work
We refer here to creative exercises that involve perhaps only a small amount of lesson time, but the scope to continue if we want outside of the classroom. Projects spark interest in a topic, encourage research, and give the opportunity for those who are interested to delve into a topic in far greater depth. We recognise potential problems such as students going off track and if part of a group activity, one person doing far more than their fair share. To get round this, teacher supervision needs to be carefully structured.
– Does your department use project work to challenge students through research? If you do what approach do you use to introduce project work? Do you ease students into such schemes or do you simply give one large project for them to complete? Have you ever considered giving your students a whole topic to study/research on their own as a means of reducing your workload? It might be useful to discuss the advantages / disadvantages of such a method
3. A lingering thought-provoking idea
At the end of a class the teacher could present an open-ended question that requires consideration beyond the classroom. Ideas can be taken up in the next lesson with students volunteering to provide answers.
4. Enthusiastic Teachers
We assume that all teachers are enthusiastic, but how should this show itself in the eyes of the students? We look for a teacher who has prepared the lesson well, who takes an interest in each individual, and who conveys their subject in a way that is both educational and entertaining. An enthusiastic teacher encourages enthusiasm amongst their students. It would help if teachers were given more freedom to personalise their lessons, including scope to give their own opinions. We recognise that the wider working environment might influence teacher enthusiasm.
How enthusiastic are you? Is it even possible to tell or measure a teacher’s enthusiasm? Do you think enthusiasm is important to teaching & learning?
5. Challenging Lessons
We all agreed that this was essential and we attempted to identify what the phrase means. It is when the content goes further than the syllabus with students pushed beyond their usual limits. Quite possibly unconventional ideas will have been introduced. The lessons should be structured but unpredictable and if they are successful they will have kept the students interested throughout. The key constraints might be that fellow students are unable to keep up or feel alienated. If challenging work can’t be provided for some students within a class, maybe there should be separate classes for the more able or smaller classes or perhaps higher level lessons should take place outside of school.
Do you see challenging lessons as something which ought to be in all lessons or something used occasionally?
6. Discussion and Presentations
We enjoy the opportunity to give opinions. More students are likely to be involved if at least sometimes the discussions take place in small groups rather than for the whole class. Teaching time could be saved if each group is given a different aspect to cover and feeds back to others. We think that this type of opportunity to teach others improves understanding and in general, active learning results in better recall. Potential dangers include students not working together effectively, but if teachers set up the groups carefully, give clear instructions, and impose time restrictions for each task, then it can be successful. “Talk Factory could be a tool for directing useful group work.
7. Relationships
It is important for a teacher to get to know the members of their class. This will allow them to tailor work to suit each individual’s interests and abilities. From our point of view, it would make teachers more approachable, earn respect, and help to create a friendly atmosphere. This in turn would make it more comfortable for us to ask questions. There is a danger within such an environment of boundaries becoming blurred and discipline suffering. However, if teachers act professionally, avoiding favouritism and bias, perhaps by allocating equal time to each student, this threat can be overcome