Who's up for a challenge - Part 1.
In improving as teachers, we are not collecting tools, we seeking to change our habits… the things we do automatically every day. (Dylan William)
CHALLENGING LESSONS
Challenge - a demanding or stimulating situation
Why are challenge important to the classroom environment?
They:
Motivate
Raise achievement
Stretch and challenge all students
They engage with G &T learners
Remind us all that learning is making sense of the world around us rather than just remembering
So what makes a challenging lesson?
Challenging lessons need to:
1. Move away from reproductive
2. To simple reasoning tasks that are mainly closed
3. To challenging reasoning tasks that have an element of open-endedness (where learner asks what are the alternatives)
2. To simple reasoning tasks that are mainly closed
3. To challenging reasoning tasks that have an element of open-endedness (where learner asks what are the alternatives)
4. This precipitates the learner to ask topic/subject specific questions
5. This allows the teacher to measure ‘Observed Learning Outcomes’
5. This allows the teacher to measure ‘Observed Learning Outcomes’
How can I engineer a challenging lesson?

Unfortunately most students, and many teachers, have a ”folk psychology” view of learning rather than a constructivist view, and this is very hard to budge. Folk theory is considered a real obstacle to effective teaching and learning.
Folk psychology assumes:
- Knowledge is stuff
- The mind is a vessel
- Learning is storing stuff
- Acquisition only requires listening reasonably attentively, or even just being there.
- Assessment is stock taking
- Analogies for learning involve transfer rather than constructivism:
Teacher as petrol pump attendant filling student’s empty tanks.
Try and identify what approaches to teaching we might have to adopt – or already do – to help students construct their own meaning and develop high order thinking? Try and incorporate the word challenge into your ideas if you can.
Constructivist Teaching Strategies
Learning should involve activities to process the new material, linking it to what the student already knows.
Tasks should be: authentic,
set in a meaningful context,
and related to the real world.
They should not just involve repeating back facts as this causes ‘surface’ learning.
As student’s learning will involve errors, tasks should offer opportunities for:
self-assessment, correction,
peer discussion,
peer discussion,
teacher feedback and other ‘reality checks’.
Use:
- ‘Teaching by Asking’ or guided discovery
- Explaining tasks that require students to express their understanding to each other, and to develop this understanding before expressing it (e.g. peer explanation, and Jigsaw)
- Ask ‘diagnostic’ question and answer, and use wrong answers to explore and correct misunderstandings. ‘Socratic Questioning’.
- Use thought provoking tasks and questions that are high on Bloom’s Taxonomy, rather than simple recall as these require more thought and processing:
- Analysis: ‘why’ questions,
- Synthesis: ‘how’ could you.. questions
- Evaluation: judgement questions.
• These high order questions require students to construct their own conceptions of the new material. You can’t reason with material until you have conceptualised it, so questions that require reasoning force conceptualisation and subsequently ‘high-order’ understanding
• Use Case studies that relate the topic to real life or former experience and so former learning
• Use Group work requiring students to discuss the material, so that peer checking and teaching takes place
• Learning involves ‘pattern making’, so use mind maps and summaries that point out the relation of the parts of a topic to the whole. Also point out the relation of today’s topic to other topics
• Teach skills in the context of the topic of your subject. Think of yourself as a skills teacher who uses content to teach the skills.
• Stimulation increases the learning rate. So use rich multi-sensory resources, lively activities and generate a sense of fun where you can.
Good students may create meaning from passive methods, but weak students do not. Both types of student improve their learning enormously when they are required to use it.
Try to identify the most useful teaching strategies you could use so you can fulfill the criteria identified above .
There are three characteristics or ingredients to creating challenging lessons.
1/ The usefulness of Constructivist thinking –the importance of understanding the process of learning. Recognise that we all have our own unique way of ‘understanding’ (the way we make links between abstract ideas in our minds)
2/ The need for teachers to - “understand learning through the eyes of their students” (as a way of recognizing the numerous reasons why sometimes students don’t understand what teachers are telling them)
3/ The application of ‘deliberative practice ‘- this is where teachers deliberately ’engineer’ lessons in order to challenge all learners through a variety of innovative way
Perhaps the Holy Grail of challenge are lessons that lead to Flow, where the challenge levels are continually just ahead of the level of skills:
Flow: Where challenge and skill levels are high.
