Thumbs down for Hands up?

A scenario repeated in classrooms near you?. Teacher asks a question. A few hands shoot up - always the same hands. The hands that aren't raised instead prop up drooping heads, or twiddle pens. "When teachers ask questions, it's always the same few pupils who put up their hands. The others can slip below the teacher's radar, and therefore tune out," says Professor Wiliam.
So instead of a show of hands, the teacher would ask pupils at random to answer any questions. There was resistance at first.
"Those who didn't usually raise their hands were shocked that they had to pay attention. Those used to volunteering an answer were nonplussed by their removal from the spotlight," he says.
Teachers found they had to plan their lessons in more detail, formulating questions to draw out pupils who'd fallen out of the habit of responding in class.

A compromise was for the teacher to randomly pick two pupils to answer, then ask if anyone had anything to add, giving habitual answerers a chance to pitch in.
In this clip, Professor Dylan Wiliam observes a classroom habit that is so ingrained that nobody thinks to question it. Hands-up to answer a question.

Source: Where hands-up in class is banned -  

Newer Post Older Post